Ask almost anyone and they will likely say that espresso has way more caffeine than regular drip coffee. This assumption makes a perfect sense. What else would explain the buzz we get when we down a shot of espresso in the morning?
Interesting, but is this correct? Well, that depends on your perspective...
During the 1950's a typical serving size of coffee was between 4 to 6 fl oz (118-177mL), but over the years our "cup" size has grown almost eight times since. Starbucks' smallest cup ("short") is 8oz, while their largest cup ("venti") came in at about 20-24oz.
But in 2011 Starbucks topped this by introducing the "trenta", which measured in at a whopping 31oz of coffee. Yes, almost a quarter-gallon of coffee! Talk about a caffeine buzz!!
Starbucks Serving Size
short (8oz), tall (12oz), grande (16oz), venti (20-24oz)
According to the National Coffee Association (NCA), a typical cup of drip coffee (8oz) contains approximately 65-120 mg of caffeine. Not exactly a tight tolerance on any scale, but why is there such a large variation in caffeine content?
Well, without getting overly technical, there are several factors to consider when brewing coffee. Factors such as brew time, dwell time, water temperature, grind level, roast level, bean type, blend, etc., all have a significant effect on the final extraction of caffeine. But more on this later.
Now, if we look at the level of caffeine contained in a typical cup of drip coffee and espresso those figures come in at about 92.5 mg and 40.0 mg, respectively. Remember these are averages, so the exact amount will vary based on establishment.
As you can clearly see drip coffee with approximately 92.5 mg contains a larger concentrations of caffeine than espresso - how much more? On average about 2.3x more!
So there we said it - drip coffee has MORE caffeine than espresso! Case closed, go home, right?
Well, not exactly!!
If we take this approach, it's actually an unfair comparison, so we need to compare "apples to apples".
A more correct approach would be to compare the two beverages in terms of their caffeine concentration per ounce (oz).
In the case of drip coffee, we need to divide the 65-120 mg of caffeine by its serving size, resulting in a caffeine concentration of approximately 8.1 - 15 mg/oz. That means that for every ounce of coffee solution we can expect ~8.1-15 mg of caffeine present.
Whereas in espresso, even though we start off with about a 1/2 to 1/3 less caffeine, remember all this caffeine is contained in just 1 oz of liquid or expressed numerically as 30-50 mg/oz.
Meaning that in just 1 oz of espresso solution we get has about 30-50 mg of caffeine.
So What Does All This Mean?
Although we can conclude that drip coffee has at least 2x more caffeine than espresso, we need to consider that this is due to much larger serving size.
Obviously since espresso is served in much smaller volumes, we get less caffeine - when considered from a beverage perspective.
But when viewed from a volume perspective, espresso has much more caffeine than drip coffee.
The Bottom Line
So, what's the verdict?
Does espresso really have more caffeine than drip coffee?
Well, the answer really depends on your perspective. If we look at this issue from a:
- beverage perspective - drip coffee has more caffeine
- volume perspective - espresso has more caffeine
The following images below show what you consume when you purchase either an espresso (~1oz) and a standard cup of coffee (8oz). That is, if you consume an espresso you'll take in about 30-50mg of caffeine, while a drip coffee about 65-120mg. Of course, these are simply averages, but you get the gist.
Comparison of Caffeine Content in Drip Coffee (8oz) vs Espresso (1oz)*
|65-120mg (BP)||30-50mg (BP)|
|(8-15mg) (VP)||(30-50mg) (VP)|
*(BP) = beverage perspective, (VP) = volume perspective
So Why Do Most People Believe Espresso Has More Caffeine Than Regular Coffee?
Well, part of the reason this belief has continued to exist is because caffeine itself is an intensely bitter compound. Since espresso is roasted at a much darker roast, which creates a higher concentration of 'bitter' molecules - the logical "connection" would seem correct - but it is in fact incorrect.
The bitter compounds that arise from darker roasts are not due to caffeine, but rather bitter compounds created during the Maillard reaction.
It is this much lower concentration of caffeine (per serving) in espresso that allow Italians to drink upwards of 5 to 10 espresso's per day without getting overly jittery. Try drinking a dozen 12 oz cups of drip coffee and you'll likely end up with a visit to the hospital from excessively high levels of caffeine in your system.
Unfortunately it is very difficult to "standardize" the caffeine of coffee beverages since numerous variables need to be considered, including:
- Beverage Size - are we comparing a cup at 4oz, 5oz, 12oz or 24oz?
- Blends - many roaster create their own blends of various beans each with subtle difference in caffeine content
- Bean Type - is the blend 100% arabica, robusta or both?
- Grind - was the coffee prepared with a fine grind, ultra fine grind, coarse, etc?
- Water Temperature - was the coffee prepared with the recommended 195-205°F temperature range?
- Milk - was milk added or not - as this will dilute the caffeine content
- Others - machine type, dwell time, etc.
All these factors make the calculation of caffeine in coffee beverages a real challenge. Hopefully, with the implementation of industry standards by trade organizations, we can begin the journey towards creating more standardized cups of coffee in our industry.